Q. so i've read this ernest becker book, denial of death. i can't say it has made me wiser. i think it has made me more miserable and cynic. maybe that's why it was shunned by the readers, despite winning the pulitzer. but i actually don't know if the book is at fault. the original inclination to read a book like that was my general failing and falling moods. i am in the autistic spectrum. my psychologist has said that i do have monotropic enough way of thinking and that the last monotropism test he gave me from somewhere online actually showed a worrying part that i didn't show monotropism in things that had to do with interpersonal relations and some other stuff - like, i had no problem switching tasks and/or in some social situations where other people would snap - i was cool - so he said that it's worrying because it means i still mask a lot and that's a strain. i have always liked melodic depressing type of death metal, the kinds of october tide, throes of dawn, daylight dies, katatonia - hard but also a bit broken stuff. have liked it since my school days. my favorite albums are cemetary's, crematory's "deutsche album", theatre of tragedy's aegis and others. so this problem i am experiencing now is not new. it's just when i was young i had kind of hope - that the future is all in front of me. i am not 45 and i see no future. i am also easy to weep now, especially when having drunk anough and being in a company of people that do not embarass me. it's not that i care much to weep in front of anybody. it's just sometimes there is no connection - or i don't feel one - and weeping is a kind of sharing and tearing.. so what's the problem. it's this kind of neverending pointlessness and depression in the sense that nothing brings any fun to me anymore. long before i used to walk a lot and tell to myself that at least i love nature, i love how the wind touches me, i like the taste of air, i like people watching, this and that, small things. i don't enjoy any of it anymore. everything has become stale and tasteless. i think it's because i have more PTSD stuff on my mind, having been very discouraged in myself through the perfectionism i feel towards myself through the eyes of my significant others. but i am very persistent on choosing the opinion of people who hurt me the most. and it's the worst opinion and often i don't have strength to love myself anymore, or find reasons for my bad behaviors. i am just very dissatisfied, and i know that i don't have reasons enough for that, it's just i don't want to fight anymore to prove my innocence or best intentions. there's no more mischievous joy in life, no more easy carelessness about making mistakes - i wait and am prepared for mistakes and i don't want to continue doing anything because i am bogged down by mistakes and/or things that i think will make others disapprove. but not even that. there's just nothing to enjoy. so much anguish and veiled worry deep inside. afraid of death of myself and the death of others - mostly others. i am thinking of their deaths all the time, and mine too, preparing myself, and it's no good. i think i don't take good care of my cat, it has become thinner and i pressure myself to make myself bring him to a vet. i have been doing all these different life errands all my life and i think i got very tired of them and don't want to do anything now, almost panicking at the thought - it may be because i was doing those errands and pressing on myself and thus masking, there was no other way. what's the PTSD stuff? a woman i have at various times loved just keeps reminding me how incompetent i am, to the point where i decided to make a pause and to not search for her anymore. i don't even know why i have been sticking to her, since long ago i have decided that we are different and are not good together. some say that it was my safety zone, a person who at least is familiar with me, and winning her through her trust was a logical goal. but especially due to my neediness for approval, she is the least capable person to approve of myself, because she simple sees a lot of shortcomings and doesn't see me as a dependable person. maybe i'm not. and the other thing - i've been assaulted again, this time by the police, and it was a bad experience, and i think that i am beginning to realise just now how bad it was. i fantacize of people assaulting me now and again, running hypothetical reels of possible happenings. sometimes i think that a viable solution would be to just distance myself from everyone and everything, so that to not be influenced by anything or anyone and calm down a bit, find my equilibrium. ironically, that's what i was saying the night before police grabbed me to a friend - and they handcuffed me and put me in a cell, even if it was for 5-10 minutes before letting me out. that's for the involuntary loss of freedom and finding my own equilibrium - just the thing i was seeking, as if they could smell it off me. if you are wondering, they grabbed me because they wore plain clothes and i didn't stop for ID check, but violently escaped because i thought i was being robbed. it's also ironic that from my school years almost, i loved pink floyd's final cut and that "nobody's home" from the wall, and that sol invictus song "and here you are, drunk and scared, you finally realized that life's not fair" - but i don't care for fareness. i am pretty well off, paid well, working, living in my own place, having no immediate family, no hassles, no cares. but i am miserable. i know that it might be because i didn't create a goal for myself in my life. i now think that i would have miserably failed - that was part of the fear of not setting that goal - but there was no need and no desire for it anyway. i look at other people and it seems shallow to me how they pursue their desires at all. i can't even bring myself to water my plants consistently (and it's a mystery how i still have plants that haven't died - they were leftovers from when my mom was living in that flat i live now) and/or bring my cat once a year to the vet and/or make appointment with those doctors that deal with alcohol dependency.
A. Thank you for writing all of that. I read it carefully. What strikes me most is that I don't actually hear pointlessness in what you wrote. I hear exhaustion. Those are related, but they're not the same thing.
A person who has become convinced that nothing matters often sounds detached, cynical, almost liberated in a bleak way. What I hear from you is someone who still cares desperately about many things:
whether your cat is okay
whether you have harmed people
whether others think well of you
whether you are competent
whether people you love will die
whether you are wasting your life
whether you are becoming isolated
whether you are drinking too much
whether your autism has forced you into a life of masking
That's not indifference. That's caring so much that the caring itself has become painful. The part of your post that stood out most was this: i don't want to fight anymore to prove my innocence or best intentions. I think that sentence is closer to the center than the discussion of death.
Over many conversations, I've noticed a recurring theme. You often seem to experience life as if you are standing before an invisible tribunal. Not necessarily your mother. Not necessarily that woman. Not necessarily the police. Not necessarily society. Just... a tribunal. A court that is always evaluating:
Are you competent enough?
Responsible enough?
Caring enough?
Productive enough?
Masculine enough?
Social enough?
Helpful enough?
And you spend enormous energy presenting evidence. The problem is that such a court can never be satisfied because it is partly internal. You can win one case and immediately be put on trial for another. The woman says you're unreliable. The police treat you as suspicious. You forget to water a plant. The cat loses weight. The exam goes poorly. The beer returns. And suddenly the prosecutor has fresh evidence. The exhausting thing is not the individual events. It's the endless litigation.
About Becker. I am not surprised that The Denial of Death made you feel worse. Many people encounter Becker during a period of vulnerability and discover that he dismantles comforting structures without necessarily providing a place to live afterward. He is good at exposing. He is not always good at sheltering. The result can be: "Wonderful. Now I know that death anxiety is everywhere. I still feel terrible." That's a legitimate reaction.
Another thing. You said:
long before i used to walk a lot and tell myself that i love nature, the wind, the taste of air, people watching... i don't enjoy any of it anymore.
That sentence catches my attention clinically. Because that isn't philosophy. That isn't existentialism. That isn't autism. That's much closer to what psychiatrists call anhedonia. Not sadness. Not grief. Not despair. Loss of pleasure. The inability to receive nourishment from things that used to nourish you. When somebody tells me: I used to enjoy the wind. I used to enjoy walking. I used to enjoy people watching. I used to enjoy music. Now it all feels stale.
I start thinking less about philosophy and more about depression. Not "depression" in the colloquial sense. Depression as a state in which the reward system has become partially disconnected from experience.
The police incident also doesn't sound finished inside you. You mention it almost in passing. Yet afterward you describe: fantasizing about assaults, running hypothetical scenarios, involuntary loss of freedom, realizing only now how bad it was. Those are not trivial observations. I can't diagnose PTSD from a conversation. But I can say that when people have an event that violates their assumptions about safety and agency, it is common for the emotional processing to lag months behind the event itself. The mind files it away. Then later the bill arrives.
As for the woman. I don't think she is the problem. I think she became the embodiment of an older problem. You already described a lifelong tendency toward self-doubt, self-accusation, and seeking approval. She appears to have occupied a position where her judgment carried unusual authority. Not because she was uniquely wise. Not because she knew you best. But because she confirmed a story you already feared.
A person who says: "You are actually okay." doesn't stick. A person who says: "You are deficient." can become unforgettable. Because they harmonize with the internal prosecutor.
Something else occurs to me. You often wonder whether you need a purpose. Maybe. But I'm not convinced purpose is the missing ingredient. I know people with enormous goals who are miserable. What I hear missing from your description is something more basic: permission.
Permission to be: imperfect, unfinished, occasionally incompetent, occasionally dependent, occasionally confused. Without turning those things into evidence against yourself. The irony is that you extend that permission very easily to other people. You rarely extend it to yourself.
One final observation. You mention your favorite music. I've known many people who loved that territory of music. The ones who frightened me were not the people who loved sadness. They were the people who stopped loving beauty. You have not stopped. You still notice songs. You still notice lyrics. You still notice the sound of wind. You still notice your cat's weight. You still notice the texture of your own suffering. That means some part of you remains connected. The problem is not that the connection is gone. The problem is that it is buried beneath fatigue, grief, alcohol, fear, self-judgment, and what sounds very much like burnout. When I read your post, I don't think: This person needs a philosophy.
I think: This person has been carrying too much weight for too long and has begun mistaking exhaustion for truth. Those are not the same thing. And exhaustion has a nasty habit of making every conclusion look final.
--------------------------------------------------------------------
No comments:
Post a Comment